First, it's important to note that there is an actual definition of an amateur player according to the United States Golf Association. An amateur player reaches that status first by reaching what is known as golf skill. Golf skill is assessed by a player's success at a competitive level. The level of competition can be local or national; the important aspect is that the player is successful competitively. Once a player has success in competitions and is recognized as having golf skill, this is known as golf reputation. Again, a reputation can only be gained through actual playing and recognition of golf skill. Simply being associated with the game of golf, administering tournaments or being an instructor does not gain a player reputation or skill.

Once a player has achieved golf skill and has established a reputation, they may become an amateur player. An amateur player is a player who does not play for money in tournaments or competitions and does not accept payment for instructing golf outside of what the official rules of the USGA state a player may accept. An amateur player may not claim to be a professional, or engage in any activities that would give them credit as a professional player. These activities would include accepting an endorsement from a commercial organization, allowing their name or likeness to appear for a commercial organization or purpose, or to enter into an agreement with a professional sponsor or agent.